preview

Minimum Price Floor

Decent Essays

1. Yes, I believe that the establishment of a minimum floor price is consistent with the free trade principles of NAFTA since a minimum floor price doesn't truly affect the free trade between the two countries. I think that it is important to first look at the definition of a minimum floor price or a price floor. The Economic Times state "Price floor is a situation when the price charged is more than or less than the equilibrium price determined by market forces of demand and supply. By observation, it has been found that lower price floors are ineffective. Price floor has been found to be of great importance in the labour-wage market." Mexico clearly has the competitive advantage in growing tomatoes and Florida farmers realize that. Early …show more content…

I believe that imports from Mexico have grown over the years due to the fact that Mexico's tomatoes have lower labor costs. Until the labor costs, quality of tomatoes and technological investment declines then we probably will not see the Mexico stop being a top importer for the United States of America. The United States of America is ranked third for the amount of tomatoes that it is able to produce but Mexico is still the largest in agricultural imports. Investopedia states Mexico is the biggest source of all agricultural imports for the U.S. Last year, the U.S. brought in $5 billion worth of vegetables through November, an increase of a little over 4% as compared to the entire year of 2015. Tomatoes, onions and bell peppers are popular vegetable imports from …show more content…

I think that it was fair for the Commerce Department to establish a new minimum floor price. It showed that the department realized that Mexico had a competitive advantage against Florida and they tried to make the best out of the situation. This price floor had been in for 16 years prior to be changed and I think it was a necessary change. If they would've filed an antidumping suit it would have disarranged the whole agreement. Tomato producers all over the United States would've benefitted from an antidumping suit since it could have possible deterred Mexican farmers from wanting to export to the United States of America. An important fact to note is that states like Florida and California would have been able to capture some of the tomato market share within the United States of

Get Access