preview

As Good As It Gets Udall

Decent Essays

The movie “As Good As It Gets” released in 1997, stars Jack Nicholson as Melvin Udall and Helen Hunt as Carol Connelly and Greg Kinnear as Simon Bishop. In the movie Melvin is an author lives his life as recluse in his New York City apartment. He is not well liked among the people he is around on a daily basis. Melvin is known for not liking people or dogs and is forced to take care of his gay neighbors (Melvin is also known to not like gay’s) dog while recovering from his wounds after a robbery. Melvin goes to his usual restaurant where he is always served by the same waitress, Carol, (no other serve will wait on him because he is so awful to deal with) only to find out she is out to care for her sick son. Melvin then goes to Carol’s apartment …show more content…

After spending time together Melvin starts to fall in love with Carol as well as finding that he is starting to become fond of his neighbor’s dog that he is caring for. Throughout the movie, Melvin Udall exhibits abnormal behavior. Not only does Melvin show misogynistic behavior, racist behavior, as well as homophobic behavior but he exhibits signs of obsessive-compulsive disorder (also known as, OCD). To accurately diagnose someone with obsessive-compulsive disorder a clinician would benefit most by using a multifaceted approach including different perspectives. No matter the approach taken a clinician will refer to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (2013), also known as The DSM-5 (2013). The DSM-5 is used by clinicians for official definitions of mental disorders and the criteria needed to diagnosing mental disorders and dysfunctions. The DSM-5 criteria for diagnosing Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder is in section 300.3 of The DSM-5. The patient will have either an obsession, compulsion, or both. As stated by The DSM-5 (2013), …show more content…

Melvin believes he does not need to behave in a socially acceptable manner, and has difficulty with interpersonal relationship, and a hard time with finding the proper way to handle emotional responses, which are not typical behaviors and is not related to OCD. These are signs of possible personality disorder, such as narcissistic personality disorder and schizoid personality disorder. For purposes of this paper I will concentrate on how he presents his OCD.
As explained by Seibell in the article “Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder”, (2015) it often takes many years before the correct treatment is obtained for an individual with OCD. Melvin seeks treatment as an adult because of his developing relationship Carol. In the movie he explains to Carol that he has sought treatment from a psychiatrist and is taking medication to help him with his

Get Access